The backlash against Big Tech on Monday moved into a new phase as officials from nearly all US states announced an antitrust investigation into the dominance of Internet giant Google.
The announcement from 50 attorneys general calls for a probe into whether Google abused its power in the online ecosystem at the expense of rivals or consumers.
The move, described as a preliminary probe of Google’s actions in online advertising, highlights the growing complaints about Big Tech dominance and follows a separate investigation into Facebook Inc announced last week by a coalition of US states.
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton said that the probe underscores fears about how Google benefits from data harvested from the online ecosystem.
“What we’ve all learned is that while many consumers believe the Internet is free … the Internet is not free,” Paxton told a news conference in front of the US Supreme Court in Washington.
“There is nothing wrong with a business becoming the biggest game in town if it does so through free market competition, but we have seen evidence that Google’s business practices may have undermined consumer choice, stifled innovation, violated users’ privacy and put Google in control of the flow and dissemination of online information,” he said.
“The question for us is whether Google has strayed from its founding principles to not do evil,” Utah Attorney General Sean Reyes told the news conference.
“We’re looking into whether Google’s business practices have undermined free market competition — and hurt consumers,” Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro added.
The probe is being backed by 48 states — with only California and Alabama absent — and joined by Puerto Rico and the federal District of Columbia.
Officials stopped short of calling for any specific remedies such as a breakup — which some Google critics have called for.
“It is an investigation to determine the facts,” Paxton said. “Right now it is on advertising, but the facts will lead where the facts will lead.”
Google senior vice president of global affairs Kent Walker said in a blog post on Friday last week that the company would cooperate with regulators, while stressing that its services “help people, create more choice, and support thousands of jobs and small businesses across the United States.”
According to research firm eMarketer, Google leads the US digital ad market with a 37.2 percent share worth about US$48 billion this year and is expected to control 20 percent of all US ad spending, online and offline combined.
Google is by far the largest online search engine and captures nearly 75 percent of search-related online ads in the US, according to eMarketer.
Christopher Sagers, a professor of antitrust law at Cleveland State University, said it was potentially “very significant” to see the state coalitions working on antitrust.
“After the past few years, the [US President Donald] Trump administration’s antitrust program has come to seem pretty inactive, influenced by a lot of politics that have made it hard to interpret,” Sagers said.
On Friday, New York state Attorney General Letitia James announced an action on behalf of seven other states and the District of Columbia to probe “whether Facebook has stifled competition and put users at risk.”
The antitrust actions come against a backdrop of declining public trust in big online firms, and fines levied against Facebook and Google over privacy violations.